Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Leading in the middle's avatar

I agree that AI will likely replace large parts of administrative management work such as reporting, coordination and performance tracking. And I also think many organizations have layers of management that add too little real value today.

At the same time, I wonder if this perspective may underestimate a very human need that still seems highly relevant, especially among younger employees entering the workforce.

Many are not necessarily asking for less leadership. In my experience, quite a few are actually looking for clearer expectations, more frequent feedback, stronger recognition, measurable progress and closer guidance in navigating complexity and uncertainty.

It also makes me reflect on whether we sometimes mix up ineffective management with leadership itself. There is probably a meaningful difference between managers mainly focused on coordination and reporting, and leaders who help create clarity, trust, direction and growth.

Being seen, understood, challenged and encouraged by another person feels fundamentally different from receiving automated insights or recommendations.

It actually makes me wonder whether the rise of AI could increase the value of good people leaders rather than reduce it. Especially leaders who are able to create belonging, psychological safety and meaning in increasingly complex organizations.

Elina's avatar

This way of rethinking the management role is actually quite invigorating. Though I think if we reduce the manager purely to maker and product designer, the counterargument becomes that every IC should become this builder too, so why need manager.

I think what comes with the leadership role is an extra layer of orchestration: between the customer you're building for, the organisational vision, commercial viability, and the peers and parallel workstreams across departments. And the users that require empathy aren't just end customers, they are the team, the stakeholders, the peers. As they develop not a product but an entire department they lead within other complex systems.

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?